Roadmap 0.11, Requests for 0.8

GH.2 Proposal: non-destructive modifier stacks for grouped geometry

  • Feature
  • Decision Time
  • ModelCraft

# Non-destructive modifier stacks for grouped geometry

## What do you need to do

I would like to contribute a small, non-destructive modifier workflow for product modeling in ModelCraft. The goal is to preserve a group's source geometry while applying editable operations in sequence, so changing an earlier parameter updates the final shape without manually rebuilding it.

The motivating use case is a dimensioned lamp: edit a shade's proportions and repeated parts, keep the modeling recipe, then reuse ModelCraft's existing materials, lighting, rendering and export workflow. This overlaps the modifier-based subset of Autodesk 3ds Max requested at https://remade.wiki/software/autodesk-3ds-max/. It would not imply native `.max` support or full compatibility.

I checked the public issue/PR search for “modifier” and found no existing proposal. Is comparable work already planned or underway? Would this fit ModelCraft's direction?

## How do you do it today

This is a proposed workflow, not a report of my current professional use. From source inspection at `b077b70`, ModelCraft already provides direct edits, transforms, groups/components, undo/redo and dynamic component stretching/repetition. `dynamic.js` retains a source reference for regeneration, which looks like a useful precedent.

I did not find a general reorderable modifier stack. Undo history alone does not provide an editable modeling recipe.

## Suggested first increment

- Opt in for a group containing ordinary mesh geometry; keep current direct editing unchanged for other objects.
- Preserve the source geometry and a short ordered operation list.
- Start with local-space Scale and linear Array; edit parameters, reo…

Opened on GitHub by a Discord member: https://github.com/getcadcraft/modelcraft/issues/4

Waits on: Owner: push modelcraft with PR #5's commit kept (approved 10-29), post the review (model-08.md); stack built in /lab. PR unchanged 11-05

From: a Discord member

modelcraft#4 open

Add a comment

Community comments

No comments yet

Add detail as we go: how you would use it, files or steps that show the problem, what other programs do. The team reads every comment.

Sign in or create a free account to add a comment.