Resources

Numerical accuracy

The calculations in our apps: the policy each one is under, the precision it runs at, and the code itself.

This device: processor, memory, graphics The standard Precision is not robustness

  • 941 calculation policies
  • 6,917 calculations in 1,248 source files
  • 143 exact
  • 6,286 in 64-bit
  • 335 with a 32-bit step
  • 437 open items
  • Last reviewed

Calculation policies

A policy says how one family of calculations keeps its precision. Open one to see its calculations, by source file, and their code.

  • Line sizing and pressure drop

    Works out velocity, Reynolds number, friction factor and pressure drop of each line, picks pipe sizes, and fills the stream table that is drawn on the P&ID.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    13 calculations in 3 files
    64-bit
  • Line, arc and circle intersections

    Where two drawn objects cross: the basis of snaps, trim and extend.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    4 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Linetype dashes

    Cuts lines and arcs into the dashes, gaps and dots of their linetype for the screen and for plots.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    2 calculations
    64-bit
  • Lineweights in a DWG file

    Converts a lineweight between its value in hundredths of a millimeter and the index a DWG file stores.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • ModelCraft
    • TakeoffCraft
    • CivilCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    2 calculations
    Exact
  • LISP arithmetic, conversions and geometry

    The numbers a LISP routine gets from the built-in arithmetic, number and angle formatting, unit conversion and point geometry functions.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    12 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Load flow and short-circuit currents

    Bus voltages, branch flows and losses of an AC network, and fault currents by symmetrical components.

    Every app 64-bit, stated limit
    12 calculations in 3 files
    64-bit Open item
  • Load reserve and escape route checks

    Finds the load factor at which a design first reaches its limit, and the narrowest door on the best way out of every room.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • DetailCraft
    • PartCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    3 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Luminaire files and point-by-point illuminance

    Reads luminaire photometry files (IES LM-63 and EULUMDAT) and works out the direct illuminance on a grid of points, with its minimum, average, maximum, uniformity and power density.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    17 calculations in 2 files
    64-bit
  • Lumped system models

    Operating point and response over time of electrical, thermal, hydraulic and mechanical networks built from lumped elements.

    Every app 64-bit, stated limit
    12 calculations in 3 files
    64-bit Open item
  • Magnetic and electric field solvers

    The field of wire segments, the mutual inductance of loops, and 2D finite-element magnetic and electric fields with energy, capacitance and force.

    Every app 64-bit, stated limit
    12 calculations in 2 files
    64-bit Open item
  • Map layers under the drawing

    Draws map pictures and tiles under the drawing, warped from the map's coordinate system to the drawing's.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    Display only
    2 calculations
    32-bit, display only
  • Map layers: web Mercator, tile grids and world files

    Converts longitude and latitude to web Mercator and back, lays out the tiles of a map service, reads a picture's world file, and writes the box of a map request.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • CivilCraft
    64-bit, direct
    10 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Map pictures warped onto the plan

    Picks the tile level for the screen and cuts a map picture into pieces that are each drawn with one affine transform.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • CivilCraft
    Display only
    3 calculations
    32-bit, display only
  • Markers: pieces laid on fabric

    Keeps the pieces of a marker on the fabric, checks grain direction and overlaps, and works out the marker's length and fabric use (Apparel add-on).

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    9 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Member axes and section properties

    Works out each frame member's length and local axes, and the area, second moments and torsion constant of a section from its outline.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • DetailCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    6 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Meshing a slab or wall into plates

    Cuts a slab or wall outline into four-node plates and places their nodes in the frame model.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • DetailCraft
    64-bit, direct
    12 calculations in 2 files
    64-bit
  • Model points written to USD

    Writes the vertices and edges of a model into USD meshes and curves.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • ModelCraft
    • TakeoffCraft
    • CivilCraft
    • DetailCraft
    • PartCraft
    32-bit step, flagged
    2 calculations
    32-bit in part Open item
  • Molar mass and group-contribution estimates

    Works out a molecule's formula and molar mass from its structure and estimates boiling point, critical constants, formation energies and heat capacity by Joback's method.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    4 calculations
    64-bit
  • Molecular dynamics

    Simulates atoms under Lennard-Jones, bonded and Coulomb forces and reports temperature, pressure, energies, density, radial distribution and diffusion.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    22 calculations in 3 files
    64-bit Open item
  • Move, rotate, scale and mirror

    Applies a move, rotation, scale or mirror to drawing objects, and places block references and viewports.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    8 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Move, rotate, scale, mirror, array, stretch and lengthen

    Builds the transform or the length change for the modify commands from the picked points and typed values.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    10 calculations
    64-bit
  • Moving a grid line with what hangs on it

    Moves a grid line sideways by a distance and carries the walls, columns, bubbles, tags and dimension points that sit on it.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    2 calculations
    64-bit
  • Multileader geometry

    Works out what a multileader draws: its line with the landing, the arrowhead and where the text starts.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    2 calculations
    64-bit
  • Nesting add-on: outlines in, placed copies out

    Reads closed outlines and their holes from the drawing as parts for the nesting engine, and writes the placed copies and sheet rectangles back.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    5 calculations
    64-bit
  • Number conversion in LISP variants

    Converts the value of a variant to another type when a LISP program asks for it.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    1 calculation
    64-bit
  • Number text in USD files

    Writes numbers into .usda text and decides which attribute types are 32-bit and which are 64-bit.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • ModelCraft
    • TakeoffCraft
    • CivilCraft
    • DetailCraft
    • PartCraft
    32-bit step, flagged
    3 calculations in 2 files
    32-bit in part Open item
  • Numbers in a DWG file, read and written bit for bit

    Reads and writes the number codes of a DWG file: full and compressed 64-bit values, whole numbers of several sizes and object handles.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • ModelCraft
    • TakeoffCraft
    • CivilCraft
    • DetailCraft
    • PartCraft
    64-bit, direct
    16 calculations in 2 files
    64-bit
  • Numbers in the frame analysis report

    The values printed in the analysis and design report tables, which are also what the CSV and PDF downloads contain.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • DetailCraft
    64-bit, direct
    10 calculations in 5 files
    64-bit Open item
  • Numbers sent between people editing together

    How a number in an edit is written into a Studio Live message and read back on the other side.

    Every app 64-bit, direct
    5 calculations
    64-bit
  • Numbers typed into the property grid

    Turns what a person types or drags in a Properties row into the number handed to the app.

    Every app 64-bit, direct
    3 calculations
    64-bit
  • Objects on a tilted or flipped plane mapped to the plan

    Maps circles, arcs, polylines, text, block references and hatches that a file stores in their own coordinate system onto the drawing's plan.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    6 calculations
    64-bit
  • Offcut stock after nesting

    Works out the usable material left on a plate after a nest, keeps it as numbered remnants with their size and area, and nests the next job on remnants first.

    • CadCraft
    • PartCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    13 calculations
    64-bit
  • Offset, extend, break and lengthen

    Offsets an object by a distance, extends an end to a boundary, breaks an object between two points and lengthens or shortens it by an amount.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    5 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • P&ID line geometry and connections

    Works out where process and signal lines run, how long they are, and which symbols and lines they are joined to in a P&ID drawing.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    15 calculations in 4 files
    64-bit Open item
  • P&ID placement, zones and values written to the drawing

    Places P&ID symbols on process lines and connection points, cuts lines around inline symbols, draws hazard zones to scale, and writes imported stream values and relief sizes into the drawing.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    8 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Paper sizes, drawing scales and viewport aim

    Turns a scale 1:n and the drawing's units into a viewport scale, picks the standard scale at which a view fits, and sizes the space a new sheet leaves for views.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    10 calculations
    64-bit
  • Parameter expressions

    Evaluates the formulas typed for parameters and dimensions: arithmetic, units, trigonometry in degrees, rounding functions and comparisons.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • PartCraft
    64-bit, direct
    11 calculations
    64-bit
  • Parameters and equations

    Evaluates named parameters and the equations that drive dimensions, writes the results into the drawing or part, and solves backward for a parameter when a driven value is edited.

    • CadCraft
    • PartCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    9 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • Parametric PCB footprints

    Pad positions, pad sizes and the courtyard of standard-style footprints, worked out from pitch, row spacing and pin count.

    Every app 64-bit, stated limit
    7 calculations
    64-bit
  • Part labels on label sheets

    Places a label for every piece on a printable label sheet and sizes its bar code.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • ModelCraft
    • PartCraft
    64-bit, direct
    2 calculations
    64-bit
  • Pass or fail against a regulation limit

    Decides whether a found value meets the minimum, maximum or range of a regulation rule.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    • CivilCraft
    • DetailCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    1 calculation
    64-bit
  • Pasted picture size

    Sizes a pasted picture, or a copied area pasted at its true size, in drawing units.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    3 calculations
    64-bit
  • Pattern outlines: curves, lengths and areas

    Turns the points of a clothing pattern outline into a smooth curve, and measures lengths, areas and positions along it (Apparel add-on).

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    10 calculations
    64-bit
  • Pattern piece lengths, seam walking and areas

    Measures the sew line of a pattern piece: edge lengths, the distance round the outline between two points, seam walking against another piece, and the perimeter and area per size.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, direct
    4 calculations
    64-bit
  • Pattern pieces from drawing geometry

    Makes a pattern piece from polylines, arcs, circles and ellipses of the drawing, places notches on it and moves its points by grips (Apparel add-on).

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    9 calculations
    64-bit Open item
  • PDF page vectors and snapping to them

    Reads the lines, curves and text of a PDF page into page points, and finds the end, middle, crossing or nearest point of those lines for snapping.

    • CadCraft
    • BimCraft
    32-bit step, flagged
    8 calculations in 2 files
    32-bit in part Open item
  • PDF underlay in a plot

    Plots the lines, curves, fills and text of a PDF underlay at its place in the drawing.

    • CadCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    1 calculation
    64-bit Open item
  • PDF underlay placement and PDF import

    Places a PDF page at its true size in the drawing's units, and turns a page's lines, arcs, circles, fills and text into drawing objects.

    • CadCraft
    32-bit step, flagged
    13 calculations in 2 files
    32-bit in part Open item
  • Pen sketch cleanup

    Decides what a freehand stroke was meant to be (a line, circle, arc, rectangle or polyline) and makes that exact shape, then joins nearby ends.

    • CadCraft
    • MarkupCraft
    64-bit, stated limit
    9 calculations
    64-bit

A policy is added only after its source was read. Each statement can be checked in the code shown on its page; the app repositories are public. When a release changes a calculation, its page says so until it has been read again.

The standard

  • 64-bit everywhere

    Every calculation runs in 64-bit floating point (IEEE 754 double precision), from the number you type to the number you read.

  • 15 digits, always

    A 64-bit number keeps any 15-digit value intact and takes 17 digits to write out in full. Our rule for every calculation: carry all 17 between steps, and order the arithmetic so that avoidable rounding never costs one of the first 15.

  • 32-bit gets a warning

    A 32-bit number keeps about 7 digits. Where a 32-bit step can reach a number you read, the calculation is flagged in the lists below, and the app will warn that the result can have less mathematical precision.

This device

The apps calculate in 64-bit on every device. Work handed to the graphics processor is the exception: browsers expose graphics processors as 32-bit calculators, which can provide less mathematical precision.

A browser reports a rounded or capped view of the machine, never a full inventory: it gives the number of processor threads (not the model), memory rounded down and capped at 8 GB (Chromium only), and one graphics adapter even when a machine has several. What the browser reports about graphics is a capability, not a measurement of the card. The size of a graphics card's memory bus (a 192-bit bus, for example) says how fast data moves, not how precisely it calculates. Most graphics cards can calculate in 64-bit natively, slowly, but WebGL and WebGPU do not offer it to web pages.

Approaches

Every policy takes one of five approaches to keeping its precision.

Exact values 8 policies
Constants and factors are held as exact fractions from their definitions. The arithmetic is ordered so that no rounded factor is ever used.
Exact predicates 1 policy
Coordinates are 64-bit. The yes-or-no decisions that shape the geometry (which side of a line, inside or outside a circle) are computed exactly, so rounding cannot flip one.
64-bit, direct 337 policies
Every value is a 64-bit number from input to result. Formulas are closed form or a direct solve, and every comparison uses a stated tolerance.
64-bit, stated limit 428 policies
The arithmetic is 64-bit, but the method or the data sets the accuracy: a solver tolerance, a mesh, a step size, a datum shift, a table. The limit is stated where the result is shown.
Display only 49 policies
Computed to draw the screen, often in 32-bit on the graphics processor. No number a person reads, saves or exports comes from it.
32-bit step, flagged 118 policies
One step stores or exchanges 32-bit values that reach a number a person reads. It is listed here with its open item, and the step is either moved to 64-bit or the app will warn where the number is read.

Precision is not robustness

Mathematical precision is how many digits a number keeps. Geometric robustness is whether a shape stays valid: every intersection found, every solid closed, every face joined to its neighbors. They are different properties, and a CAD system can have the first without the second.

Every geometric algorithm rests on yes-or-no questions. Is this point left or right of that line? Do these two edges cross? Is this point inside that circle? Each answer is the sign of a small expression. When three points are almost in line, the true value of that expression can be smaller than the rounding error of the arithmetic that computes it, and the sign comes out wrong. That happens at 15 digits as readily as at 7.

One wrong sign is not a small error in the last digit. It is a different decision: an intersection that is missed, two triangles that overlap, a face that points the wrong way, a solid with a gap in it. Every coordinate can be correct to 15 digits while the shape they describe is invalid.

A point C almost on the line from A to B. Magnified, C is a tiny distance to one side of the line. A B C C left or right?
C lies a rounding error away from the line through A and B. Which side it is on decides how the geometry is built.

What makes geometry robust

  • Exact predicates

    The yes-or-no questions are answered exactly. The fast 64-bit answer is used when it is safely away from zero. When it is not, the sign is computed again with as many digits as it takes.

  • Decide once

    A decision about a shape is recorded as topology, and every later step agrees with it. The same question is never asked twice with a chance of two answers.

  • Stated tolerances

    Where a tolerance is used it is written down, scaled to the size of the geometry and applied the same way everywhere.

  • Local origins

    Coordinates far from zero are moved to a local origin before the work, so the digits are spent on the geometry and not on the distance to the origin.

  • Valid by construction

    Algorithms whose result is guaranteed to be a closed solid, whatever the input, in place of ones that repair the result afterwards.

  • More than the language

    These choices matter more than the programming language. JavaScript, C++ and Rust all compute with the same 64-bit numbers: the same algorithm is as robust, or as fragile, in each.

Where our apps stand

The list on this page records both properties. Surface triangulation in CivilCraft and BimCraft uses exact predicates. Solid modeling in PartCraft runs on a kernel whose result is a closed solid by construction. The intersections in the CadCraft app use stated tolerances today, and exact tests for the near-parallel and near-tangent cases are an open item. Each policy says which approach it takes.